River cruise or ocean cruise? Two 7-night voyages compared, AmaMagna on the Danube and Queen Mary 2 in the Norwegian Fjords: ships, food, staterooms, and the real cost.
River cruise or ocean cruise? It’s the question we keep coming back to on our travels, so we put two of this year’s voyages head to head: a 7-night cruise along the Danube on AmaWaterways’ AmaMagna, from Budapest to Vienna through the Wachau Valley, and 7 nights through the Norwegian Fjords on Cunard’s Queen Mary 2. Both were cold-weather voyages on two of the most popular itineraries in cruising, which makes them a fair comparison of two very different ways to travel: shores you leave behind against shores within touching distance, freestyle days against curated ones, and pay-as-you-go against barely thinking about the bill.
The ships set the tone. AmaMagna is tiny next to Queen Mary 2 but a giant of river cruising, a rare double-wide vessel carrying just 196 guests and 70 crew, with four dining venues, an open deck with pool and hot tub, a cinema, a gym, and the Main Lounge at the heart of every evening. AmaWaterways used the extra width to give each guest more space, not to carry more of them. Queen Mary 2 is the last great ocean liner, Cunard’s flagship, carrying 2,691 passengers and 1,292 crew, with seven dining venues, eight bars and lounges, a world-class theatre, the Queens Room, the Grand Lobby and the most beautiful promenade deck at sea. One is small, intimate and personal. The other is a floating town of choice, where you shape your own time.
That difference shapes every day. Our Queen Mary 2 balcony fare covered regular dining and entertainment but not excursions, Wi-Fi, drinks, speciality dining, the spa or transfers. Our AmaMagna balcony fare included excursions, Wi-Fi, speciality dining, drinks with meals and transfers. In Olden, we booked a Cunard excursion to the Briksdal Glacier, trekked at our own pace, warmed up with a hot drink and cake at basecamp, and still had time to explore town before dinner in the Britannia Restaurant and dancing in the Queens Room. In Vienna, we chose our excursion the night before: a horse-drawn Fiaker ride and walking tour to St Stephen’s Cathedral, before breaking away for the Votive Church light show and the Kunsthistorisches Museum as the snow fell. AmaWaterways had a coach waiting for anyone who stayed out late, and when it left the moment we boarded, we discovered it had been running just for the two of us.
Food is where the two diverge most. Ocean cruising wins on choice and flexibility: buffets, poolside burgers, grand dining rooms and speciality restaurants. River cruising is quality over quantity. On these two voyages, dinner on Queen Mary 2 was fine but no more, with speciality dining a clear step up at extra cost. On AmaMagna, it was the best food of our year, with every speciality venue included and guests encouraged to try them all. Evenings follow the same pattern: live music and local performances on AmaMagna, perfectly suited to early nights after full days ashore, against theatre shows, pub quizzes, string quartets, ballroom dancing and fjord views from the Commodore Club on Queen Mary 2.
In the staterooms, our Queen Mary 2 balcony was fine, if dated, with awkward power outlets and a shower curtain straight out of the 1970s. AmaMagna’s was in another league: modern, spacious and more boutique hotel than ship cabin. Then the cost, excluding flights. Our Queen Mary 2 balcony was £3,302, plus £357.79 spent on board for the glacier excursion, drinks and a spa day. Our AmaMagna balcony was £4,410, and our onboard bill was zero: every excursion, from Schönbrunn Palace and Melk Abbey to a full day in Český Krumlov, plus transfers, speciality dining, wine with dinner and Wi-Fi, already paid. A fare gap of £1,100 becomes about £750 once you count what you spend on board, and it would close further on an ocean cruise with an excursion in every port.
So which is better? Queen Mary 2 through the Fjords feels like an expedition: remote, spectacular places reached on an iconic ship that carries you back to the golden age of ocean travel. AmaMagna on the Danube feels like the heart of Europe, a run of the city breaks you always meant to book, with a ship and crew that feel entirely yours. Floating town against moving boutique hotel, and both have their own magic. We came off the Danube sold on river cruising, and three ocean voyages later we still are. For us, it isn’t river or ocean. It’s what you’re in the mood for, and which itinerary catches your eye.